"Ecological
Consequences of Artificial Night Lighting is an
excellent
reference that will undoubtedly raise awareness of the need to conserve
energy, do proper impact assessments, and turn down the
lights." -David Hill
in Science
The
Conservation Planning
Program is responsible for statewide
oversight of various approaches used to balance the needs of
threatened, endangered, and sensitive species and habitats with the
needs of land users.
The
Institute for
Ecological Health
-
The Institute for Ecological Health facilitates harmony between human
communities and their natural ecosystems. We link the conservation of
rural landscapes and a viable agricultural economy to the conservation
and enhancement of wildlife habitat, native biodiversity and ecological
functions.
Cosumnes River Preserve- The Cosumnes
River Preserve
encompasses and protects thousands of acres of wetlands and adjacent
uplands. The Cosumnes River Preserve is recognized as one of
California's most significant natural areas. Cosumnes
River Preserve Management Plan - DRAFT
Notes: The Management Plan now contains the following language.
CHAPTER 6 – ACTIONS
2.1.4 As new development projects proposed around the
Preserve,
... ensure that project proponents to consider potential
effects
on visual resources at the Preserve, including the effects of outdoor
nighttime lighting.
2.2.1 Prior to installing new outdoor lighting for the
Preserve,
the lighting shall be reviewed to ensure consistency with Objective 1.2.
The
Endangered Species Act (ESA) and it's relation to Outdoor Lighting
Could the
effects of Outdoor Lighting constitute a "taking" under the ESA?
The answer
is, without question YES!
see the following
Loggerhead Turtle v.
County Council of Volusia County, Florida, 148 F.3d 1231 (11th Cir.
1998).
Loggerhead
Turtle v. County Council of Volusia County, Florida, 896 F. Supp. 1170
(M.D. Fla. 1995).
Could a city along a water way fall under this act if it's docks, and
river front cast light onto the water?
If lighting increases predation of a listed species, then the
municipality must be authorized
accidental takes of the subjec species.
"Harm" includes
"significant habitat modification or degradation where it actually
kills or injures wildlife by significantly impairing essential
behavioral patterns, including breeding, feeding, or sheltering."
National
Wildlife Refuge System Notes
601 FW 3 Biological Integrity, Diversity, and Environmental Health C. Environmental Health. (3) At the population and community levels, we consider the
habitat
components of food, water, cover, and space. Food and water may become
contaminated with chemicals that are not naturally present. Activities
such as logging and mining or structures such as buildings and fences
may
modify security or thermal cover. Unnatural noise and light pollution
may
also compromise migration and reproduction patterns. Unnatural physical
structures, including buildings, communication towers, reservoirs, and
other infrastructure, may displace space or may be obstacles to
wildlife
migration. Refuge facility construction and maintenance projects
necessary
to accomplish refuge purpose(s) should be designed to minimize their
impacts
on the environmental health of the refuge.
http://www.fws.gov/policy/601fw3.html
Media
Coverage
Recent story
in Sacramento
Bee The
salmon
lovers return to Old Sac, By Lisa Heyamoto - lheyamoto@sacbee.com
November 27, 2007
If you've been hanging around Old Sac these days, that barking you
hear isn't the coyotes fighting for a piece of the nearby downtown
railyard.
Nope, it's a pack of vocal sea lions – a rookery, if you will, because
apparently I'm obsessed with collective animal nouns.
About
this time each year, the marine mammals travel to our bend in the river
in pursuit of the savory salmon run, conveniently congregating near the
Delta King. Manager Mike Coyne says it makes for a pretty
spectacular spectacle for
paddleboat passengers.
"What's kind of fun is when they're right off the boat and they're
fishing," he said.
In
case you didn't know, the difference between sea lions and seals is all
in the ears – as in, sea lions have them and seals don't.
As for what they end up deciding about that railyard, we're all, all
ears. **
What Lisa and others don't understand is that the lighting
around the Delta King and Docks are why the salmon are easy picking for
the sea lions. It is wall documented that predation increases
in areas with lighting along rivers during salmon runs and during out
migration.
We in this quote form Ecological
Consequences of Artificial Night LightingPage 266
provide just
one documented example. "Lights
along a migratory watercourse may allow increased predation by other
vertebrate predators.
Both inmigrating adult and outmigrating juvenile salmon are captured by
mammalian and avian predators, which can exert a significant pressure
on depressed fish populations (Yurk and Trites
2000). On
the Puntledge River in British Columbia, Canada, lights from a bridge,
halogen lights from a recreational field, and halogen lights from a
sawmill facilitated foraging on outmigrating smolts by harbor seals
(Phoca vitulina; Yurk and Trites 2000).
A "lights-out" experimental treatment at the bridge reduced the number
of seals feeding, but on subsequent nights the seals
repositioned
to exploit illumination from residual urban light." Search
note [seals
salmon preditation +lighting +bridge]
[seals
salmon predation +lighting +bridge]
Seeing
stars is
simple as turning down the lights , Local light
pollution
activist works to further stargazing and fight energy waste.
By Blair Anthony Robertson - Bee Staff Writer
August 27, 2007
Study:
Harsh Lighting May Damage Embryos, San Jose
Mercury News -
Aug 14, 2007
"Sunlight and cool-white fluorescent lights caused the most damage to
mice embryos in the study, even when exposure was limited to a few
minutes, said Dr. Ryuzo Yanagimachi, a retired University of Hawaii
researcher known for his expertise in reproductive biology."
Cool-white fluorescents, which are blue-white in appearance, are
commonly used in office environments.
Warm-white lights, which are yellow-white in color and popular in
residential settings, resulted in "far more" eggs developing into
babies, Yanagimachi said.
"We found that warm-white light is less damaging," Yanagimachi said.
...
"People do not pay much
attention to light as a negative environmental factor," he said.
Scientists Discuss Possible
Dangers of
Nighttime LightKansas City infoZine, MO
- Feb 23, 2007 Are the
streetlights and security lights the Western world takes for
granted causing breast cancer, killing sea turtles and blocking views
of the constellations? ... More than
100 scientists,
lighting technicians and government workers
registered for the two-day conference hosted by the Carnegie
Institution, a non-profit research center. ...
Urban Glow Hides Stars, Disrupts
Animal
LifeMen's
News Daily, CA -
Feb 22, 2007 Astronomers,
whose view
of the heavens is being dimmed, are complaining, but biologists are
also decrying light pollution because they find it hurts ...
Bright
Nights Dim Survival Chances
Science Now, DC - Feb 22, 2007 At a
conference here
yesterday, researchers reported that even low
levels of light from incandescent, fluorescent, or other humanmade
sources can befuddle creatures that require a period of nighttime
darkness. The findings add to the evidence that artificial lighting is
interfering with the development, reproduction, and survival of species
across the taxonomic spectrum. ...
Urban
Glow Hides Stars, Disrupts Animal LifeVoice
of America -Feb 22, 2007
As populations and cities grow, our once pristine view of the stars is
being whitewashed by urban glow. Astronomers, whose view of
the
heavens is being dimmed, are complaining, but biologists are also
decrying light pollution because they find it hurts wildlife
development and possibly human health, too. ...
Astronomers, whose view of the heavens is being dimmed, are
complaining, but biologists are also decrying light pollution because
they find it hurts ...
Bright
Nights Texas Parks and Wildlfe magazine,
June 2006 Bright
Lights, June 2006 issue of Texas Parks & Wildlife Magazine
(print page)
From fireflies to ocelots, many species are adversely affected by
ever-increasing levels of artificial lighting. " The insects
clearly pay a dear price, in the form of increased
predation by the opportunistic spiders and geckos. That may seem like a
good thing, until you consider the importance of bugs as food for
animals and pollinators for plants. For example, says Mike Salmon, a
biologist at Florida Atlantic University, reduced insect populations
force many birds to work much harder to find enough insects to feed
their young."
Plants "The periodicity and duration
of light and
darkness is powerfully important in the development of many plants. The
measurement by plants of light/dark periodicity enables them to fit
their growth patterns to the seasons, and the duration of periodic
darkness is critical for the onset of flowering in many higher plants.
Thus, relatively strong light pollution during the night (as from
street or flood lights) may seriously disturb the normal growth,
development, flowering and senescence patterns of sensitive plants."
-- Roger G.S. (Tony) Bidwell, Ph.D, “ECOLOGY
OF THE NIGHT” Symposium, September 22-24, 2003
Invertebrates
- Aquatic
As
many as 90% of the living things in our lakes and rivers are found
along their shallow margins and shores. "The implications are far
reaching and could ultimately link light
pollution to water quality. Minute zooplankton
lurk well below the
surface during the day to avoid predators, then rise to graze on algae
at night. But artificial light discourages them from venturing toward
the surface. “If their grazing is inhibited . . . effects will cascade
up the food chain,” Moore says."
-- Ben Harder, Degraded
Darkness, Conservation
In
Practice, Spring 2004 Vol 5 no.
2
Invertebrates
- Terrestrial
Insects are attracted to the
light, it is believed that in an attempt to keep the same portion of
their eyes illuminated by the light they either spiral into the light
or around it continuously. Insects can see from 300-400 nm
(near ultraviolet) to 600-650 nm (orange). There are two peaks in
wavelength activity, one at about 350 nm (near ultraviolet) and another
at about 500 nm (blue-green). It is believed that insects react
to the ultraviolet wavelengths because ultraviolet light is absorbed by
much of nature, especially by the green foliage.
"Causes
of Decline:
The cause for the decline of this species is not clearly understood. Declines
could be a result of habitat fragmentation, habitat loss, carcass limitation,
pesticides, disease, light pollution,
or a combination of these factors. Species experts believe the primary
cause of decline habitat loss and fragmentation."... Reference --
http://www.fws.gov/southwest/es/oklahoma/beetle1.htm Salt Creek Tiger Beetle
..."With
only three populations of Salt Creek Tiger beetles remaining, this
property is vital to protecting known populations from light pollution
and water quality impacts while allowing for expansion of occupied
habitat to ensure against catastrophic events. The property will be
managed in perpetuity for the beetle. This property will also provide
additional habitat for two imperiled bird species - the least tern and
piping plover."...
Reference -- http://www.fws.gov/mountain-prairie/pressrel/DC03.htm
Marine
Life - Amphibians
As
many as 90% of the living things in our lakes and rivers are found
along their shallow margins and shores.
When the researchers and
three of their students switched on the lights
at sunset one evening, the nocturnal salamanders responded with the
amphibian equivalent of pulling the covers over their heads. They
waited an hour longer than usual to get up for breakfast. ... Does a
later start for the salamanders mean fewer nightly meals and
fewer calories? Does that cut into their fertility or increase their
mortality? What does it mean for the insects that the salamanders eat
and for the predators that, in turn, eat them? Wise doesn’t yet have
answers.
-- Ben Harder, Degraded
Darkness, Conservation
In
Practice, Spring 2004 Vol 5 no.
2
"An
unobscured full moon provides about 0.3 lux. ... Squirrel tree frogs
(Hyla
squirella), by contrast, can
see well enough to navigate and forage at 0.0001 lux or less, and they
avoid activity when illumination exceeds 0.001 lux. Other frog species
favor even darker conditions."
-- Ben Harder, Degraded
Darkness, Conservation
In
Practice, Spring 2004 Vol 5 no.
2
"Most
amphibians have evolved activity patterns and sensory capabilities that
allow them to forage and interact socially under low-illumination
conditions. Thus, artificial night lighting has the potential to
disrupt normal activity and behaviour of nocturnal amphibians."
-- Bryant W. Buchanan, Ph.D. “ECOLOGY
OF THE NIGHT” Symposium, September 22-24, 2003.
California Tiger Salamander
The Santa Rosa Plain Conservation Strategy, selected references to lighting and the California tiger salamander (CTS).
"Minimization
measures would be employed in design and construction of projects in or
adjacent to conservation areas to reduce impacts to CTS, listed plants,
wetlands, and hydrology of the surrounding areas. Design-related
minimization measures could include construction during the dry season,
passageways/under-crossings for CTS, curbing to exclude CTS from
harmful areas, lighting designed to minimize off-road ground
illumination, retaining the hydrologic characteristics of the
surrounding area and avoiding breeding habitat. Construction-related
minimization measures are shown in Section 5.2." ...
"Studies have
shown that lighting can negatively impact CTS, so roads within
conservation areas or along conservation area boundaries that include
lighting systems should be designed to direct the lighting to the
roadway with minimal illumination of the surrounding area (Longcore and
Rich, 2004). Where roads are constructed or widened, it is encouraged
that they be properly designed; therefore, a reduced CTS mitigation
ratio of 1:1 will be allowed for road projects in reaches designated on
Figures 3 through 12 that meet the following criteria:
•
Constructed with exclusionary curbing along both sides of road for the
total length of roadway, and passageways/under-crossings for CTS
located no more than 200 feet apart
• Include lighting designed to minimize off-road ground illumination
..." Reference --
http://www.fws.gov/sacramento/es/documents/Santa_Rosa_Final_Conservation_Strategy/Main_body.pdf
Frogs
Bright
Lights, June 2006 issue of Texas Parks & Wildlife Magazine
- Nocturnal frogs suspend normal
feeding and reproductive behavior when exposed to light, and individual
hoppers may remain motionless long after the light is turned off.
Female frogs of at least one species are less selective about a mate in
increased levels of light — call it the closing time effect —
presumably balancing the need to be choosy against the equally
important need to survive. Male tree frogs have been known to stop
calling in areas with bright lights, and no calling means no mating,
which eventually means no frogs.
Electronic
deterrent for hungry harbour seals - "Seals wait in those
shadows until they see juvenile salmon pass by in the lights overhead
and then snatch them for a quick and frequent meal. The ease
with which the seals are able to kill the salmon due to the lighting in
that area are making it very difficult for the fish produced at the
hatchery on the Puntledge River to make it out to sea."
IMPACTS
OF FERRY TERMINALS ON JUVENILE SALMON MIGRATING ALONG ...
"Dock lighting is also observed to induce temporary/localized delays by
attracting fish, especially at nighttime. This is perhaps associated
with prey attraction and/or visibility of prey." ... "Delayed migration
of salmonids seems to happen when fish are confronted with conflicts
regarding their preferences for eelgrass, dark areas, night lighting,
or turbid zones."
With the exception of brief comments provided by Andrew Clarke of the
Environment Agency, there appears to be little information regarding
the potential effects of lighting on fish. Enquiries to clarify the
lighting levels at which fish may be affected, have been
unsuccessful. The only practical comparator level is that produced by
moonlight, which is generally accepted to be approximately 0.3-lux.
However, it must be appreciated that this 0.3-lux level will be spread
evenly over a large area of the river, and it is understood that
problems arise where a bright band of light is present across a river,
effectively forming a barrier through which fish may not pass. This is
the typical effect produced by bridge mounted lighting, as demonstrated
by the lighting design calculations. In order to minimise this effect,
it will be necessary to restrict spill lighting to the bridge deck, by
fitment of shields, or reduce the spill lighting levels on the river,
to that produced by moonlight.
Light
Nuisance
- Stonehaven & District Angling Association Case
" In 1998, Stonehaven & District Angling Association secured a
landmark UK court judgement on Light Nuisance (aka light pollution)
which has attracted widespread interest from groups as diverse as
biologists, civic societies, astronomers and others alarmed about the
intrusive impact of ever-increasing artificial light sources on the
natural environment and on the wellbeing of the individual. It is of
particular importance to game anglers."
"This expert evidence revealed that seatrout, in common with most other
nocturnal creatures, only night-adapt into an active roving and feeding
role when natural light falls to between 0.5 and 0.2 Lux, owing "inter
alia" to greater risk of predation at higher illuminance levels. There
is also a concurrent switch from colour (cone) vision to
black-and-white (rod) vision. The importance of this low illuminance
underlines the widely held opinion amongst experienced seatrout
anglers, that an unshaded full moon (around 0.3 - 0.2 Lux) is highly
ominous to fishing success."
Effects
of Artificial Light on Deep Sea Organisms
, "Extensive studies concerning morphology of deep sea fish and
crustacean eyes demonstrate a wide variety of adaptations to life in
near-darkness. In fishes, such adaptations include gross changes in eye
anatomy (Marshall 1979), as well as increased retinal photoreceptor
sizes (Munk 1966) and increased levels of visual pigment (Denton and
Warren, 1957). Several species of crustaceans exhibit analogous
adaptations, including depth-related increases in rhabdom length and
crystalline cone dimensions (review in Land, 1981; Hiller-Adams and
Case, 1984), This combination of characteristics provides high light
sensitivity required for low-light vision; however, it may also make
them more susceptible to damage from bright light."
"Numerous studies of deep sea fishes and crustaceans have demonstrated
that most of these organisms contain retinal photopigments with peak
sensitivities between 450 and 500 nm; roughly similar to the spectra of
downwelling light and bioluminescent emissions (Denys and Brown, 1982;
Frank and Case, 1988; Hiller-Adams et. al., 1988; Partridge et. al.,
1988 ). "
Potential
Impacts of Shoreline Development - City of Bellevue
WA search [Potential Impacts of Shoreline
Development]
"Pier lighting may facilitate nocturnal predation on juvenile chinook
and coho salmon by visual predators like smallmouth bass, cutthroat
trout, and piscivorous
birds."
"Shoreline development could potentially increase the rate of predation
on juvenile chinook by several principal means: ...
4) providing artificial lighting that allows for around-the-clock
foraging by predators; "
"extending the duration of predation by allowing visual predators to
forage at night (piers with artificial lighting)."
"Alteration (slowing) of migratory behavior and subsequent increased
sculpin predation rates on sockeye fry with increasing light intensity
were observed in simulated stream experiments (Tabor et al. 1998)."
"14. Artificial lighting retards migratory progress of sockeye fry,
subjecting them to increased predation. Lights from industrial areas in
south Lake Washington facilitate nocturnal foraging by piscivorous
birds."
"13. Do not permit shoreline or pier lighting unless future studies
suggest otherwise."
The
use of cage lighting to reduce plasma melatonin in Atlantic salmon
(Salmo salar) and its effects on the inhibition of grilsing
- "The effects of additional night time illumination on
circulating plasma
melatonin levels and maturation were studied in Atlantic salmon
maintained in sea cages under commercial conditions. Salmon subjected
to additional night-time lighting from November to July had
significantly lower dark phase melatonin levels (303.1±6.3 pg/ml)
compared to control fish (600.0±53.0 pg/ml) maintained under ambient
photoperiod. More importantly, as far as the commercial farmer is
concerned, only 6.1% of the group exposed to additional lighting
matured compared to 61.5% of the fish in the control group. It is
suggested that the clear effect of the additional lights on reducing
grilsing in Atlantic salmon is mediated through a reduction in the
amplitude of plasma melatonin below a putative threshold level during
the subjective dark phase."
Effect
of photoperiod manipulation on the daily rhythms of melatonin and
reproductive hormones in caged European sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax)
(.pdf)
"Exposure to light at night suppressed circulating melatonin when fish
were exposed near the surface as well as near the bottom (5m deep) of
the cage. This result points out the effectiveness of the artificial
lights used in the experiment, such as light intensity and also
spectrum, which have been shown to be of great importance
(Bayarri et al., 2002; Porter et al., 1999, 2000)."
"As regards to daily melatonin rhythms, our results in both groups
agree with the nocturnal profile reported in other teleosts, with low
values under light conditions and high values under darkness, being the
nocturnal rise as long as the dark period (Bromage et al., 2001)"
Two
ways to advance spawning in broodstock salmon
- "Salmon take their cues to mature by photoperiod. Photoperiod refers
to the amount of daylight relative to darkness in a 24 hour period.
After the winter equinox, the daylight hours increase relative to
darkness. At the spring equinox, the rate of change from dark to light
reaches a maximum. After the summer equinox, the process reverses
itself and daylight hours begin to shorten. These rates of change
influence maturation in salmonids."
Marine
Life - Sea Turtles "Artificial
lighting has had profound
negative effects on nesting behavior and success." (turtles.org)
At the loggerhead turtle
nesting grounds
in Florida, says turtle
researcher Michael Salmon of Florida Atlantic University, “the problem
is fast becoming not the amount of light at the beach but rather sky
glow from inland.” Salmon argues that the growing threat to darkness
must be attacked at its source—population centers. “Nothing covers
that,” he says, “except having a national policy that governs how
lighting is used everywhere.”
-- Ben Harder, Degraded
Darkness, Conservation
In
Practice, Spring 2004 Vol 5 no.
2
Turtles
Turtles Win at Eleventh Circuit,
Water Log 18.4
University of Mississippi - The Eleventh Circuit ruled that the county's
incidental take permit does not authorize it to take protected sea
turtles through artificial beachfront lighting because the lighting is
solely a mitigatory measure. ...
"On some mornings
since that day in 1988, Mesure and an army of
volunteers have identified more than 1,000 birds that had perished in
this way during the previous night. The Fatal Light Awareness Program
targets tenants in downtown Toronto’s high-rises, and it advocates the
use of window shades or blinds and directed task lighting at
workstations, as well as switching off lights in unused areas at night."
-- Ben Harder, Degraded
Darkness, Conservation
In
Practice, Spring 2004 Vol 5 no.
2
Rodents
Mammalian
Bats
Bright
Lights, June 2006 issue of Texas Parks & Wildlife Magazine
- All 986 species of bats in the world are nocturnal, equipped to do
best
in low light. Populations in rural areas like Devil’s Sinkhole or Old
Tunnel Wildlife Management Area still enjoy those conditions, and
lights may actually be beneficial for urban populations, attracting
insects for the bats to eat. But bright lights have been known to stop
emergence of the bats under Congress Avenue bridge in Austin, says
Barbara French, a scientist with Bat Conservation International. And
faster-flying bat species that congregate around lights to take
advantage of the insect buffet may displace slower-flying species that
avoid lights and the increased predation danger they represent.
Completion
of Heysham to M6 Link: - Planning Application 2005 Lune
Bridge
section 6.1 Street Lighting Impact Assessment Lancashire
County
Council, UK
An enquiry with the Bat Conservation Trust has confirmed that the whole
of the Lune area is one of the most important sites for Bats in North
Lancashire. There are several important Daubentons Bat (Myotis
Daubentonii) colonies along the River Lune corridor, some of which are
very close to the proposed bridge location. There are also known
colonies of Noctule and Brown Long Eared Bats together with populations
of other Myotis species (Whiskered/Brandts and Natterers) and both
species of Pipestrelle (p.Pipistrellus and p.Pygmaeus). The Bat
Conservation Trust provided an information leaflet entitled Impact of
Lighting on Bats (which is based on a document produced by Dr Jenny
Jones – May 2000). This leaflet details how artificial lighting can
affect the feeding behaviour of bats. Studies have shown that
while certain species of Bats, such as Leislers, Serotine and
Pipistrelle, will swarm around White Mercury type lighting, feeding on
insects, this behaviour is not true for all Bat species. The slower
flying broad winged species, such as Plecotus, Myotis and Rhinolophus,
avoid streetlights. It is believed that both the Plecotus and Myotis
shun bright lights as a predator avoidance strategy. It is claimed that
lighting can be particularly harmful if used along river corridors,
near woodland edges and hedgerows used by Bats. Studies have shown that
continuous lighting along roads creates barriers, which some Bats
cannot cross, for example Daubentons Bats, which move their flight
paths to avoid street lighting. As stated above, it is understood that
there are several colonies of Myotis species in this vicinity, and it
may be prudent to undertake further consultations with the Bat
Conservation Trust, in view of the protected status of Bats.